What should you ask an AEO agency's past clients?
Ask an AEO agency's past clients about goals, results, communication, setbacks and the handoff. Learn what vague answers mean before you sign a contract.
Listen for the whole story
What this guide shows
A useful reference can explain the work in plain words, including what fell short and what the client had to do.
Ask what the client needed and how its team worked with the agency.
Listen for a clear account of a setback and how the agency dealt with it.
Ask what a reported result measures and what remains unknown.

Short answer
The Answer
Ask past clients what they hired the agency to do, what changed, who did the work, how problems were handled, and whether they would hire the agency again. Ask for a specific example of each. If an answer stays vague after a follow-up, record the question as unresolved and seek another relevant contact.
I run The Answer Engine. A reference call can help you judge how an agency works with its clients. AEO means answer engine optimization: making your business easy for AI tools to find, trust and name in answers. A reference call helps you judge fit and working style. It is one input to your decision, not a full audit of a case study.We did it for our own business. Let's find out how to do it for yours. Book a call to find out how this could work for yours
What questions should you take into the call?
- What did you hire the agency to change, and why?
- What did the agency deliver, and what did your team handle?
- What changed for your business, and what remains uncertain?
- How did you hear about progress and setbacks?
- What went wrong, and how did the agency respond?
- Who did the work after the sale?
- What did the work need from your team?
- Would you hire the agency again, and what would you change?
Which past clients should you ask to speak with?
Use these eight questions to guide the call.
Ask for people who worked with the agency directly. A client who saw the work each week can describe the day to day. A leader who approved the deal can explain the business goal and the tradeoffs. Both views can help, but they answer different questions. Start by asking each person what role they had and when they worked with the agency.
Look for a business with needs that resemble yours. The match need not be exact. A firm with many locations may care about local teams and shared brand rules. A firm with a long sales cycle may care about how leads move between teams. Tell the agency what makes your own purchase hard, then ask for a reference who faced a similar issue.
Ask to speak with someone whose project is complete as well as someone still working with the agency. A former client may be able to discuss the end of the work and the handoff. A current client can describe the working relationship. Neither view is automatically more honest. Ask what each person can speak to from direct experience.
Example: You run a group of local offices and need each office to approve its own facts. A reference from a single-site business may still help you assess service. A contact who dealt with local reviews can also tell you how approvals worked across teams. Ask both about their own experience rather than treating either as a stand-in for your business.
Let the contact know you want a candid account, not a sales pitch. Ask for a call without the agency on the line if the contact agrees. Respect a request to keep business details private. If a contact cannot discuss a topic, ask whether they can describe the type of issue and how it was resolved without naming people or sharing data.
An agency may have good reasons not to share a particular name. Its client may have a privacy rule or lack time for calls. Ask what other relevant contact can speak with you, or whether an anonymous discussion is possible. If no relevant contact is available, record that gap and weigh it alongside the other facts you have.
Before the call, tell the contact which parts of the work matter to your decision. Ask: 'Were you involved in setting the goals, reviewing the work, or discussing the results?' Their answer tells you where to spend the call. If they only approved the deal, ask who saw the day-to-day work and whether that person can also speak with you. A short call with the right person is more useful than a long call with someone who only heard updates secondhand. Use the eight questions above to focus on the parts this contact saw.
See the founder's own experience before you plan your reference calls. Read the founder's case study
How do you ask what changed for the client?
Begin with the problem the client wanted to solve. Ask what they hoped to change, how they described success, and whether those goals shifted. A good account may include a goal that was missed. The point is to learn whether the agency and client had the same idea of success, not to demand a perfect story.
Then ask what the client noticed after the work began. The answer could concern the way the business appeared in AI answers, the quality of the pages it could share, or the way its team discussed results. Ask which part mattered to that client and why. If the person talks only about activity, ask what that activity was meant to achieve.
A citation is when an AI answer links to a page or names it as a source. A citation can be useful, but it is not the same thing as a sale. Ask the contact how their team drew the link between a reported change and a business outcome. It is fine if they say they could not tell. A clear limit can be more useful than a sweeping claim.
In July 2026, I earned over $100,000 in commission that I attribute to AEO work on my own sites. Ask a reference what the client can verify and what remains unknown.
Be precise about the words in a report. An AI Overview is the AI-written summary that appears on some Google results. Google says Search Console includes clicks and impressions from its AI features in the Web search type. Its guide does not describe an AI Overview-only click count there. If a reference recalls such a figure, ask what source the agency said it used and how the client understood it.
Ask the client to explain the claim in their own words and name its limits. For a separate review of a result, use a separate case study review. The reference call tells you how clearly the agency spoke about results and how well the client understood them.
Try this follow-up: 'When the agency reported progress, what did you understand had changed?' Then ask: 'What did you still need to find out?' Listen for the client's own explanation. If they cannot say what a report meant, ask whether the agency explained it when they raised the question. That discussion can show how the teams handled uncertainty and whether the report helped the client make a decision. For Google AI features, the search type is Search Console’s Web search type.
Get a starting point for your own AI search questions. Does ChatGPT name you?
What should you ask about the work and the team?
Ask who was involved after the contract was signed. The person who sold the work may not be the person who handles your account. Ask the reference who they spoke with, who made decisions, and what happened when that person was away. Look for a clear path to an answer and a named owner for the work.
Ask what the client had to provide. Your team may need to share business facts, review drafts, grant access or make choices. A reference can tell you whether those requests were clear and whether they came with enough time to respond. This helps you plan the people and time your own team will need.
Ask how the agency dealt with requests outside the agreed work. Did it explain the choice and its effect on the plan? Did the client know who could approve the change? A clear account of a change can tell you more than a generic claim that the team was easy to work with. Listen for how both sides made the decision.
Example: A buyer needs a legal team and local managers to review public claims. A reference says its own review chain took longer than expected. The buyer asks how the agency kept the work moving while the client made its decision. Use that answer to plan who will review the work and who can resolve a stalled decision.
Ask how often the client heard from the agency and what those updates contained. Frequency alone does not tell you whether an update was useful. Ask whether the client could tell what had changed, what needed a decision, and what was blocked. If the answer is vague, ask the contact to recall a time an update led to a choice.
Finally, ask whether the team remained responsive when news was less favorable. A strong working relationship allows a client to ask hard questions. The contact should be free to say that an answer took longer than expected or that a dispute was hard to resolve. The way the agency handled that moment matters more than a claim that no problem ever arose.
Ask for a walk-through of a normal request: 'When you needed a change, who did you contact? What did they need from you? How did you know what would happen next?' Follow with a harder case: 'What happened when the request did not fit the agreed work?' Note whether the client could explain who made the choice and how the team agreed on the next step. Use those answers to ask the agency who will hold those roles on your account. Use the eight questions above to cover both the work and the team.
Your local market can shape the questions you ask. Is your city or industry still open?
How do you get an honest answer about setbacks?
Ask the contact to describe a time the work did not go as planned. Give them room to think. Follow with: what did the agency say, what did your team do, and what happened next? You are asking for a sequence, not a verdict. A specific account helps you see how the parties dealt with an issue together.
If the contact says everything was great, ask what they would change if they started again. Then ask for a time the work took an unexpected turn and how the team responded. If they still cannot give an example, note the limit of what you learned and seek another person who saw the work directly.
Listen for ownership. Did the agency acknowledge a problem within its control? Did it explain what it could and could not change? Did the client know what it needed to do? A useful answer can include mistakes on both sides. Be wary of a story that blames every issue on a third party while giving no clear account of the agency's own response.
Example: A contact says a review took longer than expected. Ask when the client learned of the delay and what choices it had. The contact might explain that its own team needed more time, or that the agency had missed a handoff. Either answer gives you a better basis for a follow-up than the word 'smooth' alone.
A refusal to discuss a private matter is different from an inability to describe any working practice. Offer a less sensitive question: how did you raise a concern, and did you get a useful answer? If the person cannot answer that either, ask whether someone closer to the project can speak with you. Respect their answer and keep your notes factual.
End with the direct question: would you hire the agency again for the same need? Then ask why. A yes may come with useful conditions, such as a clearer scope or a different review process. A no deserves context too. Ask which part of the experience drove that answer and whether the same concern applies to your proposed work.
If the contact struggles to recall a setback, make the question smaller. Ask: 'Was there a decision that took longer than you expected?' or 'Was there a point when you needed a clearer answer?' Let them choose an example they can discuss. Ask what they did next and whether the agency followed through. Write down the response in the contact's words, including any limit they place on what they saw. The eight questions above include a direct question about what went wrong.
How should you use the answers before you sign?
Write down the contact's role, the kind of work they saw, and the main points in their own words. Mark what they know from direct experience and what they heard from someone else. Keep private details within your buying team. Your notes should help the team make a decision, not turn a short call into a public review.
Compare the answers with what the agency offered you. If the reference describes a small project and your scope spans many teams, ask how the proposed support will fit your needs. If the client says it did most of the review work, check whether your staff can take on that role. Resolve the difference with the agency before you sign.
Example: Your team needs a clear owner for each brand. A reference recalls working with one agency contact, but does not know who handled each brand behind the scenes. Ask the agency to explain who would be accountable for your work. Put the agreed roles in the documents your team will use to make its decision.
Look for a pattern across the people you speak with, while keeping each person's scope in view. Similar accounts of clear updates can increase your confidence in that aspect of service. Conflicting accounts call for context: the clients may have had different teams, goals or periods of work. Ask the agency about the difference without sharing private comments that the contact asked you to keep confidential.
Separate a concern from a deal breaker. An unclear answer about who will own your account can be addressed before you sign. A missing reference for a key part of the work may remain an open risk. Decide who on your team owns each follow-up and what answer would be enough to move ahead. Do not fill a gap with a guess.
Give the agency a fair chance to respond to concerns in general terms. Ask how it handles the issue for a client like you, and seek a clear commitment where one matters. Then weigh the call with the proposed scope, your team's capacity and the evidence you have reviewed. Use the reference to judge the working relationship and keep any open questions visible in your decision.
Turn each open point into a question with an owner. For example: 'Who will approve changes to our scope?' Give the answer to the person on your team who will manage the work, and ask whether it fits the way your team makes decisions. If a reference could not speak to the handoff, ask for a former client who can. If no one is available, keep that gap in the decision notes and decide how much it matters to your purchase. Compare the responses to the eight questions above with your open decision points.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a current client give a useful reference?
Yes. A current client can describe the work they see and how the agency responds to questions. Ask what role they play and which parts they know firsthand. They may not be able to describe an exit or final handoff, so ask a former client about those points when one is available.
What if the agency cannot share a client's name?
Ask why and whether another contact can discuss similar work. A client may have a privacy rule or simply lack time. An anonymous call may still help if the person can describe their role and experience. If no relevant contact is available, note the gap and weigh it with the rest of your review.
Does a vague answer mean the agency is hiding something?
Ask for a specific example that does not reveal sensitive facts. If the person still cannot answer, record that the call did not resolve your question. Seek another relevant contact or ask the agency for context. Ask what the new contact saw directly and which parts of the work they can discuss.
Should you ask a reference about leads and sales?
Yes, if those outcomes matter to your decision. Ask what the client hoped would change and how it understood the reported result. Ask what evidence the client used to connect the work with leads or sales, and record any limits the contact describes.
Can Search Console show clicks only from AI Overviews?
Google says its Search Console performance data includes clicks and impressions from AI features in the Web search type. The cited guide does not describe a separate AI Overview-only click count there. If someone cites such a number, ask what source and method produced it. Treat that as a follow-up for a separate evidence review.
What if a reference would not hire the agency again?
Ask why, and listen for the context. Find out which part of the work drove the answer and how the agency responded to the concern. Compare that account with your own needs and ask the agency a fair follow-up before deciding.
Have a question about choosing an agency? Email our team
Sources
- AI features and your websiteGoogle Search Central
- The founder's own statementThe Answer Engine
Next step
Find out what is possible for your business
Our own business has done this. Find out what it could mean for your company.
Get your free Answer Engine audit